Review of Scott Cunningham’s Wicca – Preface / Intro / Chapter 1 – Theory

Here is the first review of the Wiccan book: Wicca A Guide for the Solitary Practitioner by Scott Cunningham.

Preface

Scott Cunningham’s Wicca is new and not rooted in the past. Yet he claims that it does find its traditional roots in these ancient shamanistic cultures. Scott also details in the preface that he believes that we all have the personal power to oversee the outcome of the rituals and magics the Wiccan uses. Wicca is a highly segmented religion making it hard to find viable resources or other Wiccans to validate claims or experiences. Also it seems Wiccans don’t proselytize as a matter of fact Scott encourages those reading his book to not proselytize, though he mentions that he had a very difficult time locating information when first starting out. This would easily be remedied through gentle forms of proselytization, I’m not talking Jehovah’s Witness type or even Mormon type, but maybe a billboard in a few major cities, or even coordinating a central group to govern the potential financial aspects of bringing Wiccan temples to major cities (you know, a Wiccan sanctioned park in a major city), these would all go far in helping curious people find out more about Wicca than what they read on the internet.

Intro

One thing that impressed me almost immediately when reading the intro was that Scott blatantly states Wicca doesn’t claim to be the one true way.

Here’s the quote,

“Wicca doesn’t solicit because, unlike most western religions, it doesn’t claim to be the one true way to deity.”

This means that as a Wiccan you know you’re likely following a fairy tale, but who cares? It is your fairy tale and your beliefs make it real. Or at least that’s the way this type of claim seems in the eyes of a skeptic.

“Wicca is a joyous religion springing from our kinship with nature. It is a merging with the goddesses and gods, the universal energies that created all in existence. it is a personal, positive celebration of life.

And now it is available to all.”

This comment will take me some time to come to terms with, because I don’t believe he truly believes his last line at all. But other than that I believe this statement to be fairly believable, Wicca so far does seem to be a religion deeply embedded in nature and existence.

Chapter 1 – Theory

“Shamanism has been defined as the first religion.”

This is the first quote of the chapter and it speaks volumes to what I am about to experience. It brings up the fact that religion has been a part of our culture even before the written word. Shaman were the people a tribe would go to for medicinal attention, wisdom and knowledge, they were the ones who would discover knowledge and dispense such knowledge as either public or private knowledge. They were said to use tools like, fasts, thirsts, self-infliction of pain, ingestion of hallucinogenic substances, and concentration to gain such knowledge. All of these were supposed to place them in an altered-state of consciousness, within which they were able to communicate and commune with the gods and goddesses. The term most commonly used in the book to describe this altered-state of consciousness is ecstasy, which makes me think that Scott is leaving a few “tools” out. As stated in the primer I wrote a couple days ago, this subject highly excited my wife because she has always been of pagan belief and often was referred to the Wiccan belief systems, the one thing that usually kept her away was a concern over her personal choice of magic, which heavily related to sexuality and the belief that energies created during copulation could be used as a focal point of magical energies. So to have Scott say that the mindset that allows communing and communicating with the gods and goddesses was in fact ecstasy genuinely impressed upon her that those people she spoke to may have been right, she may in fact be a Wiccan, but only time and more chapters will tell. Let’s get into the rest of this chapter.

It seems that Scott has decided that modern Wiccans no longer do things like self inflicted pain and using hallucinogens to invoke this altered-state of consciousness. He instead believes a majority of Wiccans use things like chanting, meditation, visualization, music, and dance to “commune with deity”. He believes that these gentler methods can attain similar states of consciousness as even the most brutal of barbaric rituals. I must be honest I tend to disagree with this, because if these rituals were able to impart information like how to make fire to a species that never used fire, or how to make the wheel, why could we not enter into these altered-states to find secrets and knowledge that can help us with our day to day lives currently? We are a much more enlightened culture these days, there is no reason why we couldn’t have a single shaman within a family or all of us be shaman if these gentler methods were able to work in similar ways, there had to be a price for knowledge, they is always a price, whether it be time, money or in the Shamans case, blood and flesh. I believe that the modern Wiccan has evolved past those rituals because of the social stigma behind them, but as I said this is a belief of my own and I do intend to find out others opinion on the fact, moving on.

“Wicca teaches that nature includes a broad spectrum of mental and spiritual states of which most of us are ignorant.”

This is an interesting statement because previously in his text he mentions that you cannot be enlightened through a book, but to no longer be ignorant of these other states wouldn’t we need some form of guidance into these other states? This does not seem to afford much for the solitary practitioner. How am I to know, if I am ignorant, whether I am speaking to the Gods and Goddesses or to Steve down the block who is actually talking on a CB radio being picked up through the fillings in my teeth?

“Wicca doesn’t view deity as distant.”

This is an awesome statement, because one things I’ve always been interested in when speaking to Christians, is the fact that their God sits on a throne in Heaven, and can hear everyone in the world through his magic wireless telephone from the Jurassic period of invention. Now this may not have been an issue when it was a few hundred people, but suppose he is listening to over 6 billion people, wouldn’t that get confusing? I have to tell people to shut up when three are talking at the same time, I can’t imagine 100, let alone 1 million, now increase that by 6 thousand times through one phone line, his wireless carrier must make truckloads of cash from his overage fees. But back to Wicca and Wiccan deities, the fact that they believe their Gods and Goddesses sit beside, and rest within, them and must be called upon to speak to is a very acceptable concept to me, because I know when I want to speak with someone I either need to knock on their door or call them up, I can’t just start talking and expect them to hear me, and I imagine Gods and Goddesses are busy people they don’t have time to just drop everything when not properly asked to listen.

“The Wiccan ideal of morality is simple: do what you want as long as you harm none.” and “do nothing that will harm yourself.”

This is a very good lesson, it is the standard do unto others as you would have done unto you. But this one is like 7 up, it has a twist, it actually tells you not to harm yourself making it so that you cannot use self mutilation or other self induced pain as justification for harming others. You go Wiccans, maybe we should find a way to work this one into a Christian Bible story, I bet it would end a couple wars.

“Many people confuse Wicca and magic as if the two words were interchangeable. Wicca is a religion that embraces magic. If you seek only to practice magic, Wicca probably isn’t the answer for you.”

So what I get from this is that Wicca believes that other religions use magic, even if that religion does not, it is highlighted with the statement earlier in the chapter “Catholic priests use ‘magic’ to transform a piece of bread into the body of a long-deceased ‘savior.’” But also Wiccans believe magic to be a natural presence within nature fully accessible by anyone willing to try and harness its energies. Meaning Wiccans believe magic does not hold prejudice based on age, sex, race, creed, religion, or any other means of uniquely identifying yourself.

“Most Wiccans don’t believe in predestination. Although we honor and revere the Goddess and God, we know that we’re free souls with full control and responsibility of our lives. we can’t point at an image of an evil god, such as Satan, and blame it for our faults and weaknesses. we can’t blame fate. Every second of each day we’re creating our futures, shaping the courses of our lives. Once a Wiccan takes full responsibility for all that she or he has done (in this life and past ones) and determines that future actions will be in accord with higher ideals and goals, magic will blossom and life will be a joy.”

I liked when I first read this paragraph, it made me smile that Wiccans believe that they set their own path, they are trailblazers and don’t hold imaginary evils accountable for the other 6 days of the week. They understand that they are responsible and will be held accountable for their actions, but they will not always be held accountable in this life, but it seems in the next also. Wiccans believe in reincarnation, meaning that they believe you must account for your past deeds as well as your future deeds, this bothers me. It bothers me, because we roll back to the Christian issue of Damned from the Start. Meaning that even though I cannot, in this life, change the outcome of a situation I may have caused in a past life, I should still have to be punished for it. I don’t agree with this at all, I would almost prefer to be bad in this life and then end up a slug in the next but absolved from all of my bad deeds due to my life as a slug. Like I said, while I liked this paragraph at the beginning it ended up causing me some issues by the end, I don’t believe accountability for actions you have no control over is a good motivator for “higher ideals and goals”.

“When a Wicca is outdoors, she or he is actually surrounded by sanctity, much as is a Christian when entering a church or cathedral.”

So Scott, you’re telling me that if I was a Wiccan each time I walked outside it would be the same as if a Christian walked into a church? Ha beat that Bible thumpers! Wiccan’s are holy everywhere! Scott attempts to solidify his claim with this phrase, “Additionally, all nature is constantly singing to us, revealing her secrets. Wiccans listen to the earth.” This would almost be like the Wiccan equivalent Christians of hearing God’s voice I assume.

“The way is open. The ancient Goddess and God await within and around you. May they bless you with wisdom and power.”

I think I am going to have to give him a small pass on his initial claim that he doesn’t believe enlightenment can come from a book, I believe he truly thinks he is going to show us the path to being a solitary practitioner of Wicca.

We’ll see… honestly I’m getting more and more skeptical about his methods.

Check out my review of Chapter 2.

Advertisements

, , , , , ,

  1. #1 by Shinobi Bombay (@ShinobiBombay) on April 13, 2012 - 8:14 am

    You are of course, entitled to your opinion. Scott would have been the first one to tell you that if it didn’t work for you then try something else. The beauty about ‘Wicca’ , especially solitary, is that it is your unique design. I doubt seriously if there is one superior system or style over another because when the majyck comes down you will be surprised at who is who.

    • #2 by Derik on April 13, 2012 - 12:07 pm

      Hello Shinobi and welcome,
      You’re right I am entitled to my opinion, and this review is not complete so your response seems a bit premature acting as if I have leveled a complete assessment of the book. My reason for being skeptical should be evident, he clearly states in the preface and introduction that he didn’t believe one could truly be opened up to magic from reading a book. Yes this means that you should find your own path towards it, but who is to say you have found the path that you truly desired in the first place? There are many references within his book to ancient gods and goddesses and while I have not gotten to my review of how he uses them within the context of the book one thing stands for certain, if you believe in these gods and goddesses you know that most were said to be petty and cruel when they were actively worshiped, what would make you think your belief in them would be different? Your morals and values do not pertain to an omnipotent being. They are still an entity within nature and with that they are completely capable of fooling you into believing what they desire.

      So here’s an example of a thought process that came to mind when I was writing this:

      I noticed Thor was mentioned within the book when skimming.
      He mentions that you could not truly be open to magic through reading a text.
      He talks about invoking the gods and goddesses and even gives examples that I can use or modify for my own use.
      I want invoke Thor because I believe him to be my patron god.
      I perform the exact ritual he describes and I actually feel I have communed with Thor.
      I continue to commune with “Thor” as time goes by.
      Soon I come across a friend who is Wiccan and also communes with Thor.
      This friend is part of a Coven that performs rituals and ceremonies together and can at least tentatively affirm my friends experience as being genuine.
      Our experiences are completely different.

      How do I know I was actually communing with Thor? Could it have actually been the trickster Loki? He is well known for playing tricks on the worshipers of Thor, so this does not seem to be a far fetched concept to me. While you may disagree with this analogy, I have in fact actively studied both Norse and Greek mythology as a hobby and understand how these gods were said to have acted towards mortals, a new religion worshiping the same goes, a new form of said god, does not make.

      Or wait, maybe since as he said Wicca does not claim to be the one way, I was actually speaking with the Flying Spaghetti Monster in his non-corporal form. He did boil for our sins after all.

      I do encourage you to continue reading these reviews I enjoy the feedback and the personal view points to be expressed, just remember my writings are from a skeptical point of view, but also I was a follower of the Wiccan ways for almost 12 years prior to deciding a single method of worship could not provide sufficient enough answers to the reality of existence, even within Wicca.

  2. #3 by sariannya on April 13, 2012 - 11:51 am

    I am currently rubbing my brow. Please..as a solitary pratictioner for more then 40 years my dear will you PLEASE not use the very childish way of spelling magic? it is MAGIC not majyck…let this ole “witch” yes you can call me a *itch, ive worked hard to earn that name too. However, you will NEVER cast ANYTHING of real worth, no matter what method you go try, if you simply cannot even fathom that to speak of magic is to admit you cast and see it. If you cannot admit that, even by spelling it correctly, then you are setting yourself up for failure. Meaning that if you cannot even spell it correctly how can you expect to be taken seriously as a magic user.

    Yes long term WItch, long term pet peeve, magic is not spelled majyck, magick, majik, magik, majic, magic, or any other crap spelling. As per teachings of Gavin and Yvonne Frost, from when I was starting, if you willingy choose to miss spell anything within your spells you are showing fear of the energies you are attempting to use, which results in a misdirection of those energies, this seems very similar to what Derik is saying could be an issue.

    When one reads something, if they cannot read it ALL, like, the title of the chapter…”THEORY” please look that word up in the dictionary it will save us all some time. Now i slap you squarly you imputent puppy. Re-read, re-open that bloody mind of yours, because if you dont, your magic will be trapped behind that veil of outworlder non magical, insecure, square heads forever.

    You dont want that. Nature accepts us all as we are, thats how she created us, however, you dont see a bear eating nuts because its the squirrels opinion that its the best food in the forest do you? No, it forms its own opinions of what food is best and eats that, but the squirrel doesnt hate the bear for it, and the bears doesnt hate the squirrel for it… i know your not an animal… but if you cant understand this post is a review and another life forces goddess given right to opinion and objective reasoning..you have NO RIGHT to preach anything, you are not scott, if he has oppinion he can read and write it for himself. You do not need to defend a man who is not under attack.

    Be well, Pray often, And above all else..love where it is needed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: